Skip to content
Illustrative Central Florida residential streetscape with detached homes, landscaped front yards and mature shade trees.

Butler Bay, Windermere

Butler Bay Homes for Sale

Find Butler Bay homes for sale. Compare layouts, outdoor space and recorded rights to focus your shortlist.

Butler Bay Homes for Sale

5 listings
View all Butler Bay homes for sale

Browse Butler Bay properties by price

Search price ranges within this area while keeping the property criteria for this page.

Recent sales near Butler Bay

6 properties sold within half a mile in the last 12 months · median $1,165,000

See all sold

Understanding Butler Bay and Windermere Club

We help you compare Butler Bay homes for sale in the Windermere area, focusing on the residential community associated with Windermere Club and Butler Bay Units Two and Three. Its location off McKinnon Road between Lake Roberts and Lake Crescent gives context, but each home's layout, grounds and recorded rights drive the comparison. We keep The Manors at Butler Bay separate and help match a shortlisted address to the correct association.

Where Is Butler Bay in Windermere?

Locate Butler Bay as you explore the community off McKinnon Road between Lake Roberts and Lake Crescent.

Butler Bay Property Market at a Glance

See current public for-sale inventory and median asking price as a starting point for your Butler Bay home search.

For sale now
5
Median asking price
$1,725,000

Homes and Private Outdoor Living

Butler Bay/Windermere Club is a gated, detached-home community where individual property features deserve a close look. Some homes have private swimming pools, substantial garages and outdoor living areas, but these are features of particular properties, not shared amenities or standard inclusions. For everyday living, compare how the interior layout connects with outdoor space and whether the garage meets your parking and storage needs. If you are considering a second home, think about the upkeep you would be comfortable arranging while away, especially for a pool or landscaped yard. During a viewing, look beyond the number of rooms to how you would actually use them. A home that suits your routines matters more than a long feature list.

Everyday Connections in Windermere

These downtown Windermere facilities are local resources, not Butler Bay association amenities. Check current schedules before planning a visit.

  • Farmers Market: Town Square Park, 520 Main Street

    Visit Fridays from 9 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. for produce, seafood, baked goods, flowers and handmade items. Town-office closures can affect operation.

  • Your Local Library at 530 Main Street

    The Windermere Branch gives you a local library destination to include in your downtown routine, whether you live here year-round or own a second home.

  • Computers, Wi-Fi and Printing

    Public computers, Wi-Fi and printing at the library provide practical options when you need to get online or handle everyday documents away from home.

  • Classes and Community Events

    Library classes and events offer ways to learn and take part in local activities. Check the current calendar for subjects and dates that interest you.

The Former Country Club: What Buyers Should Know

The former Windermere Country Club golf course and clubhouse closed in April 2016, so the community name should not lead you to expect an operating golf course or country-club membership. Do not count golf, tennis, a communal pool, dining or clubhouse access among a home's benefits unless current documents establish a specific entitlement. For a property adjoining the former course, review current plans affecting the neighboring land alongside the property's own documents. A 2019 court decision addressed open-space plat restrictions, but that history is not a promise of permanently unchanged views, public access or a particular future use. We can help you identify these questions early so your comparison centers on the home and its documented rights.

Compare gated and lake-oriented settings

For a comparison with gated communities in the wider Windermere area, explore Lake Butler Sound homes for sale and Isleworth homes for sale. A community’s lake setting does not establish frontage, boating rights or private dock access for every home.

Butler Bay Homes for Sale: Buyer FAQs

Gaby Sadler, Property Specialist

Gaby Sadler

Property Specialist, Serhant

Find Butler Bay homes for sale with Gaby

Tell me your budget and plans for the home. I'll help you compare Butler Bay homes for sale, weigh layouts, outdoor space and recorded rights, and identify the details to resolve before you choose.
+1 (407) 490-0475realty@thetopvillas.com

Find Your Butler Bay Home

Looking at Butler Bay homes for sale? Start with the layout, private outdoor space and garage capacity that would support your everyday routine or time in a second home. Share your priorities with us so we can help you compare individual properties and identify the association and property documents relevant to your purchase.

Whether a pool tops your list or you prefer less outdoor upkeep, focus on the details that will matter after you move in. Contact us to discuss your Butler Bay home search.

Browse homes for sale

Explore more

More on Butler Bay