Skip to content
Front View
Side View
1 / 33

4842 Nutmeg AvenueSarasota, FL, 34231

3beds
2baths
1,612sqft
Single Family Residence
Built in 1984
$719,000
For sale
$749,900−$30,900 (4%)Reduced Nov 16, 2026
Price per sqft
$446
Days on market
30
Listed
Oct 23
MLS #A4710437Updated Nov 17, 2026

About this property

Rare 27,600 Sq. Ft. Sanctuary in Sarasota – Move-In Ready Home & Adjacent Double Lot!

This is a rare opportunity to own a massive 0.63-acre footprint in the heart of Sarasota. This unique package deal includes the move-in-ready residence at 4842 Nutmeg Ave (situated on a 13,800 sq. ft. double lot) plus the adjacent double lot (Lots 8 & 9, also 13,800 sq. ft.). Tucked away on a dead-end street in Madison Park, this combined offering provides the space and privacy of a secluded retreat while keeping you minutes from Siesta Key’s famous quartz sands and the vibrant energy of Downtown Sarasota.

There is also potential for additional footage: a petition for a Right-of-Way vacation could add approximately 6,000 sq. ft., potentially bringing your total estate to a sprawling 33,700 sq. ft. (0.77 acres).

The residence itself is designed for comfort and style. Warm hardwood floors flow through an inviting living area with vaulted ceilings, leading to a modern kitchen outfitted with granite countertops, custom cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and recessed lighting. The primary suite serves as a true escape, opening directly onto a private patio—the perfect spot for a morning coffee surrounded by greenery. With a brand-new roof (installed December 2023) and a new AC (2023), the home is truly turn-key.

Outside, the possibilities are endless. With over 27,000 sq. ft. of land, you have the canvas to create an expansive private compound, a custom pool oasis, a guest house, or a lush tropical garden.

Nature is literally at your doorstep. The property is positioned just moments from the 72-acre Red Bug Slough Preserve. You’ll have easy access to miles of shaded trails, a tranquil lake, a butterfly garden, a fishing pier, and picnic spots. It’s a slice of "Old Florida" living that is increasingly hard to find.

Enjoy the best of the Gulf Coast from this central hub:

Siesta Key Beach: 5 miles Sarasota Memorial Hospital: 4.5 miles Downtown Sarasota & the Bayfront: 6.5 miles Whether you are looking for a move-in-ready sanctuary with room to grow or a massive lot to build your dream estate, this double-parcel package offers an exceptional Sarasota lifestyle.

This deal includes PIDs 87030036 and 87030038.

Top Villas Intelligence

Projected rental revenue and ownership costs
Sign in to view rental intelligenceSee projected rental revenue, ownership costs, operating yield, and supporting evidence.
Interested in this property?
Gaby, Property Specialist
Speak to GabyProperty Specialist, SerhantGaby can arrange a viewing, answer your questions and prepare a personalized rental projection.
+1 (407) 490-0475
No pressure. Your details stay private.

Property details

Property type
Single Family Residence
Street address
4842 Nutmeg Avenue
City
Sarasota
State
FL
ZIP code
34231
Year built
1984
New construction
No
Faces
East
Rooms
7
Building stories
1
Living area
1,612 sqft
Total building area
1,802 sqft
Architectural style
Traditional
Levels
One

Stellar MLSThe data relating to real estate displayed on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of Stellar MLS. All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; the availability of any listing should always be independently verified. Listing information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.Stellar (MFR) data last updated at November 17, 2026 at 7:26 PM EST

Price & sale history

Asking price reduced by $30,900 (4.1%) since first listed.

EventPrice
Price reducedMLS #A4710437$719,000Change: −4.1%−$30,900
Listed for saleMLS #A4710437$749,900
History may be incomplete.
Explore nearby sales

Location

Front View
Learn more about this propertyGet in touch for more information
We will use your details to respond to this request and may share them with a suitable real estate professional when needed. Marketing is optional.