$700,000Price reduced by $50,000 on Oct 9, 2026
9130 Dollanger CourtOrlando, FL, 32819
- 5 beds
- 3 baths
- 2,914 sqft
Bay Hill, Florida
Bay Hill Homes for Sale
Explore a primary or second home in Bay Hill, south of Windermere in the Dr. Phillips area, where the Butler Chain of Lakes and an established golf tradition shape the community.
Bay Hill, Florida
Bay Hill homes for sale offer a setting shaped by the Butler Chain of Lakes and the neighborhood’s longstanding golf heritage. Located south of Windermere in the Dr. Phillips area, Bay Hill brings together lakeside living, Arnold Palmer’s Bay Hill Club & Lodge and nearby dining on Restaurant Row. Whether you’re looking for a primary residence or a second home, compare each property’s location, views and documented lake access. Club membership is separate from home ownership.
Explore Bay Hill Homes for Sale
27 listings
A Lakeside Community with Its Own Identity
Bay Hill has an identity distinct from neighboring Windermere. This Orange County census-designated place lies south of the town, and its property owners’ association describes the neighborhood as part of the Dr. Phillips area. Along the Butler Chain of Lakes, lakefront homes and Arnold Palmer’s Bay Hill Club & Lodge help define the residential setting. For buyers, the appeal brings together a lakeside environment, a longstanding golf connection and nearby everyday facilities. That combination can suit a full-time residence or a second home for personal enjoyment. As you compare properties, distinguish the broader setting from each home’s actual frontage, views and access to the water.
Bay Hill at a glance
- For sale now
- 27
- Median asking price
- $1,675,000
- Community area
- 2.7 sq mi
The Golf Heritage Behind Bay Hill
Golf has shaped Bay Hill for decades. The original Champion and Challenger nines opened in 1961, and Arnold Palmer first visited for a charity tournament in 1965. He took full ownership in 1975, before the PGA TOUR event moved to Bay Hill in 1979. Today, the club hosts the Arnold Palmer Invitational presented by Mastercard. Its 27 holes span the Champion, Challenger and Charger courses: Champion and Challenger form the 18-hole championship course, while Charger adds nine more. For prospective homeowners, this history explains the neighborhood’s enduring association with the sport. The course is a defining local landmark, but living nearby is distinct from holding the membership privileges needed to play.
Private Club Facilities and Membership
Arnold Palmer’s Bay Hill Club & Lodge is a private, non-equity club owned and operated by the Palmer family. Depending on membership type, privileges include golf, tennis, a fitness center, a swimming pool, dining rooms and lounges, a marina, and social and recreational events. For an owner considering membership, these facilities could shape a weekly routine around exercise, meals with friends and time on the course. They also give prospective second-home owners specific activities to consider alongside the home itself. Residential ownership and club membership are separate considerations: buying a nearby property does not automatically provide these privileges. Discuss membership options with the club when deciding which facilities matter to you.
Everyday Life Beyond the Golf Course
For residents and second-home owners, nearby dining and library resources add practical options beyond the neighborhood’s lakes and golf course.
Dining on Restaurant Row
Nearby Restaurant Row on Sand Lake Road offers casual and upscale dining for weeknight meals, evenings with friends or second-home visits.
Library Services Close to Home
Southwest Branch at 7255 Della Drive, Orlando, provides public computers, Wi-Fi and printing—a practical resource for everyday tasks.
Learning and Local Activities
The library also offers children’s learning resources, classes and events. Explore its schedule for activities that fit your household’s interests.
Understanding Community Administration
The Bay Hill Property Owners Association publishes board-meeting information, provides an assessment-payment portal and outlines an architectural-request process. Its website identifies Beacon Community Management as the manager. These resources give prospective owners a practical starting point for understanding neighborhood administration, from following board business to asking about a proposed exterior change. When reviewing a home, request the association documents and assessment details that apply to that specific property. If you have improvements in mind, review the relevant architectural process before making plans. Homes marketed under the wider Bay Hill name should not be assumed to share identical obligations or assessments.
Where Bay Hill is located
2.7 sq mi
Questions About Buying in Bay Hill
Gaby Sadler
Property Specialist, Serhant
Talk to Gaby before you buy
I can arrange viewings, answer your questions and prepare a personalized rental projection for any home you're considering.
Find Your Place in Bay Hill
Start your Bay Hill search with the way you want to live, whether that means a year-round home or a second residence for time in Central Florida. Compare each property’s location and confirmed features with your priorities, from a lakeside setting to nearby dining and learning resources. If the club is part of your plans, explore membership separately from the home purchase. Browse the homes for sale, build a shortlist and look closely at the details that would make each property work for you.